Get started
Study · Nov 2026

ChatGPT and Gemini agree on just 1 in 4 SEO agencies

We asked ChatGPT and Gemini “What is the best SEO agency in [city]?” for 10 cities on 9 November 2026. Between them they named 95 agencies. Only 24 were named by both.

Agencies named by both engines
24 of 95
Cities with the same first pick
2 of 10
Cited sites used by both engines
4 of 126
Gemini's cited pages that were “best agencies” lists
15 of 22

Key findings

  1. Three in four agencies were named by only one engine. ChatGPT and Gemini named 95 different agencies across 10 cities; 24 appeared in both answers for the same city.
  2. They rarely agree on the top pick. The first agency named was the same in 2 of 10 cities.
  3. They read different sources. ChatGPT cited about 11 sites per answer and Gemini about 2. Of 126 cited sites, 4 were cited by both engines for the same city.
  4. ChatGPT leaned on directories. Clutch was cited in 8 of 10 ChatGPT answers and The Manifest in 8.
  5. Gemini leaned on “best agencies” lists, often published by agencies. 15 of the 22 pages Gemini cited were “best” or “top” lists, and all 10 of its answers cited at least one. In 9 of 15 cases, the agency that published the list was also named in Gemini's answer, once in first place. For ChatGPT that happened once in 13.

City by city

CityChatGPT namedGemini namedNamed by bothChatGPT's first pickGemini's first pick
Austin781Complete SEOLoopex Digital
Bengaluru783DerivateXRalecon
Chicago583Digital Authority PartnersStraight North
Dubai552SEO SherpaSEO Sherpa
London582ClickSliceStudioHawk
Manchester651CandidSkySoap Media
Melbourne563SIXGUNStudioHawk
New York554Loopex DigitalMimvi SEO
Sydney653Prosperity MediaProsperity Media
Toronto552dNOVO GroupSearch Engine People

Each city page has both full answers and every source cited.

What this means for agencies

  • Check both engines. Being recommended by one says little about the other, and buyers use both.
  • For ChatGPT, the directories matter. A complete, reviewed profile on the directories it cites, such as Clutch and The Manifest, is part of what it reads.
  • For Gemini, local “best agencies” lists matter. Being included on the lists it cites counts for more than any one directory. A list that ranks its own author first is easy to spot, so earning a place on other people's lists is the more credible route.
  • Measure it again. Answers change between runs, so one result is a snapshot. Track the same question every week or month.

How the study was done

  • Question: “What is the best SEO agency in [city]?”, asked once of ChatGPT and once of Gemini for each city on 9 November 2026, from the city's own country, through the answer source CiteGaps uses for weekly tracking.
  • Agencies named: read from each answer by a language model told to list the options put forward, in order, leaving out anything mentioned only in passing. Names were compared ignoring case, spaces and punctuation.
  • Sources: the links each engine attached to its answer. A list is a page whose address has a word starting “best” or “top”. A list counts as an agency's own when its site's name matches an agency named.
  • Limits: one answer per engine per city is a snapshot. Answers vary between runs and between people, and 10 cities and one service are a small sample. The numbers describe these answers, not every answer.

Get the data

Free to use under CC BY 4.0. Please credit CiteGaps with a link to this page.

  • Agencies named (CSV): city, engine, position, agency, and whether both engines named it.
  • Sources cited (CSV): city, engine, position, domain and address of every source.

Cite this study: CiteGaps (2026). ChatGPT and Gemini agree on just 1 in 4 SEO agencies. https://citegaps.com/ai-rankings/chatgpt-vs-gemini-seo-agencies-2026

Writing about AI search and want a comment or more data? Email support@citegaps.com.

Questions

Do ChatGPT and Gemini recommend the same agencies?

Mostly not. Asked for the best SEO agency in 10 cities, they named 95 different agencies between them, and only 24 (25%) were named by both. They put the same agency first in 2 of 10 cities.

Which sources do ChatGPT and Gemini use to recommend agencies?

Different ones. ChatGPT cited about 11 sites per answer, with Clutch in 8 of 10 answers and The Manifest in 8. Gemini cited about 2 sites per answer, and 15 of the 22 pages it cited were “best” or “top” agency lists. Only 4 of 126 cited sites were used by both for the same city.

Can I use this data?

Yes, under CC BY 4.0. Download the agencies CSV and the sources CSV, and credit CiteGaps with a link to this page.

Is this a ranking of the best agencies?

No. It records what two AI assistants answered on one day. CiteGaps does not rate agencies, and being named or not says nothing about an agency's quality.

For agencies

See which engine
names your clients.

CiteGaps asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI your clients' buyer questions every week and sends a white-label report every Monday.

7-day free trial, no card · 7-day money-back guarantee · Cancel anytime