The SEO agencies ChatGPT and Gemini name in New York
We asked ChatGPT and Gemini “What is the best SEO agency in New York?” on , from the United States. These are the agencies each one named, in the order it named them, and the sources it cited.
Named by both: 4
- Loopex Digital
- Sure Oak
- Mimvi SEO
- SmartSites
Loopex Digital, Sure Oak, Mimvi SEO and SmartSites appeared in every engine's answer.
ChatGPT named 5 agencies
- Loopex Digital
- Sure Oak
- Mimvi SEO
- LinkGraph
- SmartSites
Sources it cited: clutch.co, loopexdigital.com, mimvi.com, themanifest.com, sureoak.com, google.com, linkgraph.com, smartsites.com, autumnmorganconsulting.com, tinylevermarketing.com, iconlogovector.com
Gemini named 5 agencies
- Mimvi SEO
- Sure Oak
- SmartSites
- Loopex Digital
- Thrive Internet Marketing Agency
Sources it cited: newyorkseo.company, loopexdigital.com
Not on the list?
Run the same question with your agency's name and see whether ChatGPT and Gemini name you, who they name instead and the site they cite most. Free, with no sign-up.
Awards in the November 2026 edition
Worked out from this edition's answers by the fixed rules below, not chosen by anyone. An award says where an agency appeared in these answers. It is not a judgement of its quality.
Most named
Sure Oak
ChatGPT #2, Gemini #2, average position 2.
Not awarded in this edition: Biggest riser and New this month. Biggest riser and New this month compare two editions, so they start with this city's second edition.
- Most named
- Named by both ChatGPT and Gemini, with the best average position across the two answers. A tie goes to the better ChatGPT position, then to the name in alphabetical order.
- Biggest riser
- Named by both engines in this edition and in the previous one, with the largest improvement in average position, of at least one place. A tie goes to the better average position now, then the better ChatGPT position, then the name.
- New this month
- Not named by either engine in the previous edition, with the best average position across the engines that named it now. A tie goes to the agency more engines named, then the better ChatGPT position, then the name.
Named in this edition? Add the badge
If ChatGPT or Gemini named your agency in this edition, you can show it on your site. The badge is optional, carries the month of this run, and links to this edition's page so visitors can see the answers for themselves. Please use it, or an award badge above, only if it applies to your agency.
Select the code and paste it into your website's HTML.
The full answers
Exactly as each engine answered, without links. Nothing has been edited out or added.
ChatGPT's answer
If I had to pick one, Loopex Digital would be my first choice for a specialist SEO agency serving New York City, based on its client reviews, SEO focus, and reported results.
However, the best agency depends on whether you're looking for local SEO, national rankings, e-commerce growth, or enterprise SEO.
My top 5 SEO agencies for New York (2026)
1. Loopex Digital
Best overall SEO specialist
Clutch: 5.0/5 (98 reviews)
100% SEO-focused services
Technical SEO, link building, content optimization.
Reported strong organic traffic growth.
Source:
Visit website
2. Sure Oak
Best for organic growth
Brooklyn-based agency.
Clutch: 4.9/5 (44 reviews).
Technical SEO, link building and content strategy.
Good option for long-term organic growth.
Source:
Visit website
3. Mimvi SEO
Best for NYC local SEO
Manhattan-based agency.
Strong local business focus.
SEO, digital PR and AI search visibility.
Particularly worth considering for service businesses.
Sources:
Visit website
4. LinkGraph
New York-based agency.
Clutch/Manifest: 4.9/5 (94 reviews).
SEO, content marketing, PPC and conversion optimization.
Worth considering for mid-market businesses.
Source:
Visit website
5. SmartSites
Clutch: 4.9/5 (370 reviews).
SEO, PPC and broader digital marketing.
Established agency with a larger team.
Good for businesses wanting SEO and paid advertising together.
Source:
Visit website
My recommendation
Best specialist SEO: Loopex Digital.
Best for local NYC rankings: Mimvi SEO.
Best for a growing mid-sized business: LinkGraph.
Best for SEO plus paid advertising: SmartSites.
These are shortlist recommendations, not independently verified guarantees of results. Review counts and agency rankings are useful starting points, not proof of SEO performance.
Let me narrow it down to the best agency for your business
One important question:
What type of business do you need SEO for?
I can then narrow this down to the three strongest agencies worth contacting, rather than simply giving you a generic list.
Gemini's answer
There is no single "best" SEO agency for every company because the right choice depends heavily on your industry, budget, and specific goals (such as local lead generation, national ecommerce, or enterprise-level tech). However, several agencies consistently stand out in the New York market based on verified client reviews, specialized expertise, and documented results:
Top-Rated SEO Agencies in New York
Mimvi SEO: Frequently recognized for local service businesses and multi-location brands in NYC. They excel at high-intent local search visibility, Google Maps optimization, and conversion-driven architectures tailored to competitive New York markets.
Sure Oak: Based in Brooklyn, they are a strong choice for content-led SEO, comprehensive technical optimizations, and holistic link-building strategies. They cater well to mid-market and enterprise brands looking for scalable organic growth.
SmartSites: Highly rated for a wide range of digital marketing services with a strong focus on ROI. They are well-suited for small-to-midsize businesses looking to combine organic SEO with paid search (PPC).
Loopex Digital: Known for technical SEO audits, rigorous keyword strategies, and adapting visibility for modern AI search engines alongside traditional Google results.
Thrive Internet Marketing Agency: A large, nationally recognized agency with a solid local footprint. They offer comprehensive SEO paired with multi-channel digital strategies and have adapted aggressively to AI-driven search trends.
How to Choose the Right One for Your Business
Match the Agency to Your Niche: If you are a local contractor or medical practice, prioritize an agency with a proven track record in local SEO and map-pack optimization (like Mimvi or Loopex). If you run an online storefront, look for agencies specializing in Ecommerce SEO.
Beware of "Guaranteed" Rankings: No legitimate SEO agency can guarantee a #1 spot on Google overnight, as search algorithms constantly shift. Look for agencies that promise transparency, data-backed strategies, and clear reporting instead.
Check Recent Case Studies: Ask potential agencies for examples of clients they’ve grown in competitive verticals similar to yours—ideally within the New York market, where competition block-by-block can be fierce.
How this was collected
- One live run per engine. The question went once to each of ChatGPT and Gemini on 9 November 2026 through the same answer source CiteGaps uses for its weekly tracking, asked from the United States.
- Named as answered. The agencies are listed in the order each engine put them forward, with the names it used. Agencies it mentioned only in passing are left out.
- No judgement. CiteGaps does not rank, review or endorse any agency here, and is not paid to include or leave out anyone. The awards follow the stated rules and are not a judgement of quality.
- Answers change. The same question can get a different answer tomorrow. That is why CiteGaps tracks questions every week instead of once.
- Monthly editions. Each city is re-run at most once a month. Every run is kept unedited as that month's edition, and changes compare each engine with its own answer in the previous edition.
Spotted a problem with this page? Email support@citegaps.com.
Editions
- November 2026 edition, run (latest)
Questions
Is this a ranking of the best SEO agencies in New York?
No. It is what ChatGPT and Gemini answered when asked “What is the best SEO agency in New York?” on 9 November 2026. CiteGaps does not rate agencies, and being named or left out says nothing about an agency's quality. It shows which agencies these AI assistants put in front of a buyer who asks.
Why do ChatGPT and Gemini name different agencies?
Each engine searches the web its own way and leans on different sources: directories, review sites, “best of” lists and agencies' own pages. The sources each one cited are listed above. Answers also vary between runs, so one run is a snapshot, not a verdict.
How can an agency get named?
Get listed and described consistently on the pages these engines cite, publish clear pages about the services you offer in New York, and earn mentions in local “best of” lists. Then measure: the free check asks the same question with your brand in it, and CiteGaps for agencies tracks it every week.
Is this page updated?
It is re-run at most once a month. Each run is kept as a monthly edition with its own page; this page always shows the latest, which is from 9 November 2026.
How are the awards decided?
By fixed rules applied to the answers, listed in the awards section above: Most named, Biggest riser and New this month. Nobody picks the winners, and an award is not a judgement of an agency's quality.
Other cities
- SEO agencies in Austin
- SEO agencies in Bengaluru
- SEO agencies in Chicago
- SEO agencies in Dubai
- SEO agencies in London
- SEO agencies in Manchester
- SEO agencies in Melbourne
- SEO agencies in Sydney
- SEO agencies in Toronto
All cities: AI rankings.
Show clients where AI
leaves them out.
CiteGaps tracks how ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI answers name your clients every week, and sends a white-label report every Monday.
7-day free trial, no card · 7-day money-back guarantee · Cancel anytime